It is sad that the Okemos school board and administration cannot see their way clear to offer our children a choice in math so they would have an option to get out of the "dumbed down" math now being offered and into a more rigorous program.Offer Math Choice
Math Battaglia
Okemos
Behind in Math
Advocates for dumbed-down math
such as the Connected Math Program in Okemos middle schools justify the
program based on poor performance of U.S. students in math compared to
students from Singapore of Hong Kong (June 19).
I have textbooks from these two countries. They
have nothing in common with the Connected Math units. These textbooks teach
math in an organized, incremental and clear fashion, no unguided discoveries
or excessive exploration, no homework problems using chips.
The math taught in Singapore Primary 4 textbooks
is similar to the sixth grade Connected Math units. Such is the sorry state
of our math education under math reform -- a curriculum nearly two grades
lower than the Singapore schools.
Betty Tsang
Okemos
Math Choice Matters
With Betty Tsang (Point of
View, June 7), I am an Okemos parent concerned about the math program in
our schools, particularly the Connected Mathematics Project in Kinawa Middle
School. It doesn't give students the necessary tools for success in math
and will not prepare them for high school math.
Children certainly need to understand math, but
they also need to be competent in basic math skills to establish a foundation
on which more advanced math emphasis can be built. The new math de-emphasizes
math competency.
Currently parents have no choice about whether or
not their children are part of the connected math experiment. I think this
is wrong. Let those who want it for their children sign up, but let those
convinced this is not teaching our kids math have a traditional alternative.
Kerry Jurmu
Mason
It all adds up
"Whadaya mean you can't fix
my car? You're a licensed mechanic!"
"Yeah, but I learned through the 'Exploratory
Mechanics' program. I problem solved and gained an understanding of you
car's breakdown, but, ya know, I haven't a clue about how to fix it. But
I do empathize with your frustration and perhaps we can problem solve it
by discussing together."
"You're kidding?!"
"Oh no, you see this wonderful
learning program was enacted by our school administrators who thought they
could make this program work even though it failed miserably everywhere
else.
"Anyway, they saw we were 28 of
41 repair garages in our written tests. Now we can take written tests like
nobody's business. But for some reason this 'real world' work is so confusing.
Say, can you help me add up your bill?"
Go get 'em Betty Tsang and other
parents asking for choice in Okemos math programs!
Daniel O'Malley
Haslett